If an employee is struggling to meet expectations, talk to them early. Find out what is happening, explain your concerns and give them a fair chance to improve before deciding the outcome.

Understand what is getting in the way

Before meeting the employee privately, gather specific examples of where their work falls short of the standard required. Explain those concerns clearly and give them space to respond. Describing a missed deadline or an inaccurate report is more useful than calling someone unmotivated or a poor fit.

Their explanation will help you decide what to do next. The issue may be their ability to do the job, known as capability, or their behaviour, known as conduct. It may also reflect unclear priorities, an excessive workload or missing training and equipment. These problems need different responses, so avoid assuming that every performance concern calls for a warning.

Health can also affect someone's work. If you know, or could reasonably be expected to know, that an employee is disabled, identify and make any reasonable adjustments needed to remove or reduce disability-related disadvantage. Consider further action only after addressing those needs.

Turn the conversation into a practical plan

Once you understand the concern, explain what improvement is needed and how you will support it. Record this in a performance improvement plan with specific, measurable and realistic objectives linked to the employee's role. Set out the support you will provide, who will arrange it and when you will review progress.

For example, if reports regularly contain errors, explain the checks you expect before submission and provide a worked example or training. This gives the employee something concrete to work towards, rather than a vague instruction to be more accurate.

The review period should give them a genuine chance to improve. There is no universal statutory requirement for a 30-, 60- or 90-day plan: the right timescale depends on the work, the concern and the support needed. Explain what may happen if the required improvement is not achieved, share the written plan and encourage the employee to raise difficulties as they arise.

Keep the support and progress under review

Regular check-ins help you see whether the plan is working. Discuss what has improved, where difficulties remain and whether the promised training or support has been delivered. Keep a clear record so that both of you understand the position.

If progress is only partial, explore why before deciding the next step. More time or a different form of support may be appropriate. If expectations need to change, discuss that openly rather than moving the goalposts without explanation.

Move to a formal process when necessary

If informal support has not resolved the concern, review your capability or disciplinary procedure before taking formal action. Set out the concerns, evidence and possible consequences in writing, allow reasonable time to prepare and hear the employee's response before reaching a decision. The Acas disciplinary Code's basic fairness principles apply to poor-performance cases, including those handled under a separate capability procedure.

At qualifying formal disciplinary hearings, employees have the right to be accompanied. Confirm the outcome in writing and offer an appeal. Warnings and a further opportunity to improve will normally be appropriate before dismissal, which should be a last resort rather than the automatic result of an unsuccessful plan.

If illness is affecting someone's ability to work and there is no disciplinary issue, seek advice on an appropriate ill-health capability process and support. A disciplinary warning process may be unsuitable.

Get advice before deciding to dismiss

Employees on probation or with short service still have rights. Protection against discrimination and certain automatically unfair dismissals can apply without the service normally needed for an unfair dismissal claim. Before considering dismissal, get tailored advice, particularly where health, pregnancy, whistleblowing or a workplace complaint is involved.

Adept HR can help you prepare for the initial conversation, put a practical improvement plan in place and review your options if concerns remain.

This guide covers Great Britain: England, Scotland and Wales. Northern Ireland has separate rules.

For related practical guidance, read Managing probation fairly.

Sources